Children in foster care face challenges that go beyond just safety concerns. Many of these children carry a hidden burden of shame that stems from being separated from their birth families. This type of shame is different from guilt, as it doesn’t just say “I did something bad,” but rather whispers “I’m bad.” Over time, this sense of shame can become intertwined with a child’s identity, making them believe that any mistake they make is a reflection of their worth as a person.
The trauma of being removed from their families can leave foster youth vulnerable to internalizing blame for circumstances that were out of their control. Many of these children may believe that they were taken away because they were unworthy or defective, leading them to feel responsible for the separation. This toxic narrative can manifest as a harsh inner voice that undermines their relationships, learning, and self-esteem.
One child I worked with, TJ, struggled with overwhelming feelings of shame. Despite his foster father’s reassurances, TJ would often break down during homework sessions, berating himself with phrases like “I’m stupid.” His foster father’s attempts to deny his feelings of shame inadvertently reinforced them, as Carl Jung famously said, “What we resist will continue to exist.” Freud also noted that repressed emotions will resurface until they are addressed. In TJ’s case, his unspoken shame had become entwined with his sense of self, making it difficult for him to separate his actions from his identity.
To help children like TJ break free from the grip of shame, I developed the Shamewich technique, outlined in my book “The Traumatized and At-Risk Youth Toolbox.” This intervention, based on narrative therapy and research, aims to help children recognize shame as a voice rather than an identity, fostering self-compassion.
The Shamewich intervention is designed for children aged 7-17 and involves creating a visual representation of the internal conflict between shame and self-compassion. By externalizing the shame voice and emphasizing self-compassion, children can begin to separate their worth from their mistakes. This tangible tool serves as a reminder that making a mistake does not define who they are as individuals.
For TJ, the Shamewich intervention transformed his homework sessions. By acknowledging his feelings of inadequacy and offering a compassionate response, his foster father helped him see that he was more than his shame. By providing foster youth with tools to dismantle toxic self-beliefs and cultivate self-compassion, caregivers and clinicians can support their healing and growth.
Children in foster care need more than just a safe place to stay – they need validation, support, and encouragement to see their own value and resilience. By empowering children to challenge their negative self-perceptions and embrace self-compassion, we can help them on their journey towards healing and growth.