Constellation Brands Faces Shareholder Lawsuit Over Alleged Misleading Statements
A recent shareholder lawsuit has been filed against Constellation Brands, accusing the company of providing false information about the performance of its wine and spirits business. The lawsuit, brought by shareholder Jeff Mason in New York, claims that Constellation misled investors by boasting about the momentum of its wine and spirits segment, despite a 7% decline in net sales over the past year.
The legal action alleges that Constellation failed to disclose critical information about the struggling state of its wine sales between April 2024 and January 2025. In response to declining demand for its lower-priced wines, Constellation recently sold off several of its budget offerings to focus on premium products. The lawsuit suggests that the company may have inflated its performance in the wine category prior to the sale.
Constellation’s decision to streamline its wine portfolio comes as consumers shift towards alternative alcoholic beverages, impacting traditional wine and beer categories. The company has forecasted a potential sales decrease of 17% to 20% in its wine and spirits segment for the current fiscal year.
The lawsuit also accuses Constellation of misleading investors with optimistic earnings statements that indicated growth potential in its wine division. CEO Bill Newlands’ comments during an earnings call in April 2024 about efforts to enhance the price mix and marketing spending on wine brands are cited as examples of misleading information.
Furthermore, the lawsuit claims that Constellation spent over $668 million on stock buybacks at artificially inflated prices and alleges that five company executives benefited financially from these actions. The plaintiff, Mason, is seeking damages and advocating for changes to Constellation’s corporate governance to increase shareholder influence over company policies.
Despite these allegations, Constellation has not provided any comment on the lawsuit. The scrutiny on the company’s wine segment comes at a time of uncertainty in its primary business, beer. Challenges such as President Trump’s tariffs on Mexican imports have impacted brands like Corona and Modelo, which form a significant portion of Constellation’s beer portfolio.
During a recent earnings call, Newlands highlighted concerns about the potential impact of deportation threats and layoffs on the company’s Hispanic consumer base, which comprises about half of its customer demographic. These issues are contributing to financial pressures on Constellation Brands and may further affect its overall performance in the market.